Blog

Codependents often bond with potential rather than reality, staying invested in who someone could become. This article explains how early roles and nervous system activation keep hope alive, why occasional improvement is not stability, and how to separate compassion from commitment. It includes practical checks to choose based on consistent behaviour.

When I deal with codependents, a familiar pattern pops up time and time again. That is, that codependents feel drawn to people who are emotionally distant, inconsistent, self-focused or controlling. It is often referred to in pop psychology as the “love addiction to narcissists”. While labels can be helpful, the issue here is the dynamic. One person constantly adapts, pursues, explains and over-functions and the other withholds, avoids, deflects, dominates and remains just out of reach. A classic push-pull, distancer-pursuer relationship that becomes organized around imbalance.

Codependency recovery is not as complicated as many would have you believe. The first step is awareness of symptoms and root causes. When this is established, direct action on the path to individuality is the antidote to codependency. Group therapy allows you to share that experience with others on the same path. It helps to know you are not alone in the journey. Join me on MARCH 29TH 2026 for a new round of group therapy dedicated to codependency recovery, delivered via Zoom; Plus free access to my Codependency Self-Help Program (worth 390 USD). More Details HERE

What it looks like

The pattern very rarely begins with obvious abuse or mistreatment (though that often comes later). It often starts off with a pull towards a person who is intriguing, hard to read and intermittently warm and positive. The codependent finds themself thinking about them more than they want to and this often leads to obsession, monitoring tone, replaying conversations and later, trying to get the “good version” of them back. 

When they give attention, it feels like relief and when they inevitably withdraw, it feels like a problem to solve. At this point, the codependent becomes more accommodating, more available and they convince themselves they are being loyal, patient and understanding. In the meantime, their needs become smaller and harder to name and express. This is why codependents describe these types of relationship intense. It has nothing to do with connection or intimacy but everything to do with keeping the nervous system activated. This leaves the body with too much uncertainty to settle.

Discover Dr. Jenner’s Intensive Therapy, available on demand at your own pace. Subscribe to Dr. Jenner’s 13-week Self-Leadership Program specifically designed for codependents. This program focuses on cultivating awareness and taking actionable steps towards personal growth and autonomy. Start your journey to self-leadership and empowerment with expert guidance and support.

Why it happens

Most codependents do not say to themselves “I would love an emotionally unavailable partner”. They are generally drawn to what feels familiar, and familiarity isn’t always the same as safety. If, in childhood,  they experienced inconsistent attention, conditional affection or connection that was based on behaviour, they learned quickly that closeness and intimacy has to be earned. Bringing this into adulthood, a steady, consistent, available person can feel unfamiliar and is often rejected in favor of distance and inconsistency, which can feel familiar and compelling, even if it is painful. 

The nervous system is the main driver of this pattern. It constantly scans for cues of safety and threat. It responds to sensory input from tone of voice, facial expressions, unpredictability, withdrawal and signs of disapproval. This mirrors early relationships that were emotionally uncertain and how the system adapted to the uncertainty. It becomes more vigilant, it works for connection and in adulthood, when a partner is distant, the system recognizes the old task of pursue, please, explain and appease, in order to stabilize. This process is nearly always mistaken by codependents for attraction and chemistry. In reality, it is arousal driven by old patterns of uncertainty survival. 

Parenting is where this pattern plays out. Codependents often grew up with a parent (or two) who was critical, preoccupied, depressed, volatile or self-involved. I have come to know my own codependency through this. As I was, some were required to be the sensible one, the helpful one or the mediator who kept the peace while being a caregiver. Others received praise for being easy to deal with, good or low maintenance.  In such an environment, children learn to minimise their own needs, monitor and control moods and anticipate reactions from others. They learn that they must adapt and become the emotional barometer for the family and worse still, they learn that being accepted means adapting to the environment they live in. This becomes a blueprint for adult relating.

When this blueprint meets a narcissistic or emotionally distant person, the fit seems immediate. Such things as intermittent warmth, closeness, reassurance and approval keeps the codependent invested because the system looks forward to the next moment of connection. The codependent then maximises efforts to connect through more flexibility, more tolerance, more self-abandonment. They think it’s loyalty but it is in effect, an attempt to secure safety through effort.

What to do this week

Many will tell codependents that they need willpower to find a way out and that is partly true. However, what is needed first is pattern recognition and early intervention. Firstly, recognize intensity as a data source. If you feel hooked, preoccupied or compelled to prove yourself to someone, ask a simple question: Is this attraction or activation? Does this person bring steadiness or in fact, chaos that keeps you feeling unsure. 

Secondly, shift your standards for compatibility. Don’t ask yourself how strongly you feel, ask how often they show up. Consistency is not glamorous but it is the bedrock of emotional safety. 

Thirdly, practice small acts of self-loyalty. A delayed reply to cut impulses and urges, a direct question instead of constantly hinting and set a small boundary without over-explanation or justification. These might be considered small acts but they go someway to regulating the nervous system and they have the potential to change the dynamic.

Closing

Recovery involves learning a different kind of connection: steadiness, clarity, mutuality, and repair. When those qualities begin to feel normal rather than unfamiliar, the pull towards emotionally distant partners weakens. Relationships become less about pursuit and more about two adults choosing each other.

Therapist takeaway

If your attraction is driven by uncertainty, you are not falling in love, you are trying to settle an old nervous system pattern. Willpower isn’t enough. Practice one small acts per day of self-loyalty and watch how that slowly changes everything.