Defensive Pessimism And How It Can Help You Move Forward

  • Post author:

Can you imagine a therapist telling a patient to think negatively ? To concentrate on the less positive aspects of the issues they are having ? Sounds crazy and not too healthy but there are times when this kind of thinking can certainly be justified.

Name any self-help book found on the shelves of any bookshop and you will read common themes. Positive thinking, affirmations, perfect scenarios…change your life today ! While there are many good things to be had from the pages of books written by Messrs Covey, Robbins, et al, they can sometimes be seen as quite unrealistic in terms of what happens in real life. I have often written here on the power of realistic thinking…looking at life through realistic eyes, knowing that there will be setbacks that will inevitably come along with better times. However, my strong opinion is that there is justification at times for negative thinking but only if this is targeted in a specific place.

Nowhere better can this be seen than in the case of addiction of some kind like gambling, drinking or overeating, even when trying to change a habit like smoking.  The “thrill” that comes from this is often associated with something positive. “I must have a cigarette” or “just one more coin in the slot and I could win”. Some even believe that engaging in these practices will help them in some way and for others, it is a form of escapism and instant gratification and all too often, the positive feelings do not last too long . It takes them away from what they see as the “negative” they experience in their daily lives. The effect is normally short-lived and feelings of guilt, self-loathing, fear often follow, quickly changing what they perceive as positive to negative. The cycle continues on and on…

I recently finished therapy with a young man who was a classic example of the above. Here is his story and how a dose of negative thinking did the trick.

Graham (name changed)…. a young man lost at sea.

G couldn’t have had it harder growing up. A mother who was addicted to Class A drugs during pregnancy and a father who he would never get the chance to meet. He was brought into the world unwanted to live in an insecure environment that would shape his life for years to come. Passed from one family member to another, living in children’s homes but never really have a home, G suffered years of physical, sexual and emotional abuse which left him unable to cope with daily life. At 16, he was hanging out with the wrong crowd who taught him to steal cars, deal drugs and break into homes. It was about then that the addiction that would blight his life took hold. G could not resist casinos and spent huge amounts of money trying to achieve the “big one”…that is a jackpot that would change his life. It was also an escape from the rigours of his life…he felt good when gambling, in contrast to his life outside the casino. Crippled by a lack of self-esteem, the casino was the one place he felt at home despite the destructive influence it had on him. He knew all the casino workers  and the regular “punters” personally, calling them “family”. This positive (for him) “high” that he felt while gambling was followed by days of depression, guilt and self-loathing. He would have no more money for the month, he would be terrified that his girlfriend would find out and end their relationship, he would hate himself  for days after a fix to the extent that he would lay in bed and feign illness. One day, he called me and said he would be gone for six months. Despite my pleas for information, none was forthcoming and I subsequently found out that he had signed up for a six month stint on a fishing boat in an attempt to cure his addiction. He believed that if the temptation was not there, he could be cured. This was half of the story… he owed huge amounts of money to loan sharks that he had contacted to fuel his addiction. Upon his return, he was more anxious than ever before and asked me for help. This I believed would be a monumental task due to the fact that he had never shown any motivation to stop before. I decided to use the negative feelings he felt after a fix to over-ride the positive he felt while gambling. We went at least 20 times to the same gambling hall that he had used frequently. I made him “feel” the negative feelings of guilt, worry and self-loathing, challenging him to realise how he would feel if he gave into his temptation. I reminded him of what would happen if his partner found out… I made him focus on the negative things that happen to him after the event and made him relate that to the environment that we found ourselves in. It was not easy but eventually it began to sink in and as I write he has been “gamble” free for three months.

I employed a calculated form of negative thinking, called defensive pessimism. This can lead to very positive results, according to Julie K. Norem, PhD, a professor of psychology at Wellesley College.  “We’re not talking about a general disposition to see the glass half-empty: Defensive pessimism is a strategy used in specific situations to manage anxiety, fear, and worry,” says Norem, who has conducted seminal research on the subject. “Defensive pessimists” she says, “prepare for a situation by setting low expectations for themselves, then follow-up with a very detailed assessment of everything that may go wrong.” Once they’ve imagined the full range of bad outcomes, they start figuring out how they’ll handle them, and that gives them a sense of control.

“What’s intriguing about defensive pessimists,” adds Lawrence Sanna, PhD, a professor of psychology at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, who has also studied the phenomenon, “is that they tend to be very successful people, and so their low opinion of the outcome isn’t realistic, they use it to motivate themselves to perform better.” For example, an executive is getting ready to pitch a project, and she thinks beforehand, “The client is going to be really difficult; he’s not going to like my proposal. I have to make sure I explain things very clearly.” “She uses defensive pessimism as a tool to work through all the possibilities so she’s prepared for everything, even failure,” Sanna says. “And if she does fail, she’s ready for it, so it’s not so catastrophic.”

Subscribe to Dr Jenner's Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,497 other subscribers


Dr. Nicholas Jenner, a therapist, coach, and speaker, has over 20 years of experience in the field of therapy and coaching. His specialty lies in treating codependency, a condition that is often characterized by a compulsive dependence on a partner, friend, or family member for emotional or psychological sustenance. Dr. Jenner's approach to treating codependency involves using Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy, a treatment method that has gained widespread popularity in recent years. He identifies the underlying causes of codependent behavior by exploring his patients' internal "parts," or their different emotional states, to develop strategies to break free from it. Dr. Jenner has authored numerous works on the topic and offers online therapy services to assist individuals in developing healthy relationships and achieving emotional independence.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This Post Has 9 Comments

  1. Chey

    This is great!!!
    I am so tired of hearing people blither and then complain pretending they are “thinking positively”. The only way to BE positive is to be realistic.
    I have no negative feelings when I say, or think, of the things I have control over.
    I have practiced “the worst possible case” with myself since my childhood.
    I lost 2 brothers (separate events) and several young friends to car accidents between ages 11 and 16 years.
    People would tell me I was “negative” when they would be beefing up the smallest things to pretend they were thinking positive, when they were really just fantasizing.
    In my teens people would be amazed how I would just face things head on, and when I said,” Why not? Nobody is going to die.”, they would tell me I was “negative” to say that.
    If nobody is going to die you can always try another strategy. Running away from reality is “negative” to my way of thinking.
    When you have serious problems you need to face the worst possible case scenario. Complaining about nothing is a luxury. It’s astounding how many people think they are “positive” thinkers when they fantasize then complain about the everyday problems most people have.
    Thank you for this articile, and I hope that G has the strength to keep facing up to reality and improving life by conquering the negatives realistically.

    1. There is a very fine line between pessimism that is entirely negative and being able to use potential negative scenarios for positive change. It seems you have found a way to navigate that line. Thanks for the comment.

  2. Marty

    Awareness is not only looking at the positive but looking at life without the bias.

    Chasing pleasure seems to end in suffering and addiction.

    The Ego entices is with the power of approval, accomplishment, importance as we chase these hollow goals.

  3. Marty

    The Buddhist work on desire and satisfaction.

    Does satisfaction ever meet the promise of desire.

    If you do this work, you will see the negative results of living through your desire.

    After maslovs hierarchy of needs is fulfilled, desire does not influence happiness or inner peace.

    Desire can dominate life but leads to suffering.

    1. Chey

      Perhaps it depends on how one controls their desire and it they find their own potentially achievable desires, or if they just chase after what everyone else tells them is desirable.
      Perhaps people need to be more aware of what honestly makes them feel good in an achievable and non-harmful way and then focus on the doable that brings joy.
      I keep cats. They are wonderful therapists. They have the whole Zen thing down pat overall. 🙂

      1. Marty

        Cool reply

        Awareness helps

  4. Chey

    Thanks. Good stimulating comments. 🙂

  5. Chey

    OMG Marty!! You are so cool!!! Is that a kitty cat I see in that photo!?!? I have vision problems, inflammation in optic nerve and … brain. Nothing important. 😉
    Cats are born gurus.